Schedule H Line 4a Participant Contribution Timing in Federal Form 5500 Filings: Administrative Causes & DOL VFCP Rules
In 2024 U.S. Department of Labor Form 5500 filings, 15,858 employer retirement plans (21.7% of 73,075 audited plans) reported $4,475,191,295 ($4.48B) in late participant paycheck contributions or loan repayments on Schedule H and Schedule I Line 4a.
29 CFR Section 2510.3-102: How DOL Measures Paycheck Deposit Timing
Under Department of Labor plan-asset regulations (29 CFR Section 2510.3-102), amounts withheld from an employee's wages for 401(k) or 403(b) elective deferrals and participant loan repayments become trust assets on the earliest date on which those funds can reasonably be segregated from the employer's general corporate bank accounts. While the regulation sets an outer statutory date of the 15th business day of the following month, EBSA treats that outer date strictly as a ceiling rather than a safe harbor for large employers.
For small plans (<100 participants), DOL provides a 7-business-day safe harbor. For large audited corporate plans running automated payroll feeds, Independent Qualified Public Accountants evaluate timeliness against the employer's normal payroll-to-trust settlement cycle, which is often one to three business days after payday. When a payroll batch settles behind that regular cycle, ERISA Section 406(a) and Internal Revenue Code Section 4975 require the employer to disclose the delayed remittance amount on Schedule H Line 4a and credit affected participants with lost investment earnings.
| Reporting & Audit Metric | Reconciled Count / Value | Statutory & Operational Interpretation |
|---|---|---|
| 2024 Plans Reporting Line 4a Late Remittances | 15,858 plans | 21.7% of all 73,075 audited large retirement plans nationwide |
| 2024 Aggregate Line 4a Dollar Volume | $4.48B | $4,475,191,295 reported on Schedule H / Schedule I Line 4a |
| 2024 Suspected Full-Payroll Keying Anomalies | 337 filings | Annotated when Line 4a approximates 100% of annual participant deferrals |
| 2023 Suspected Full-Payroll Keying Anomalies | 380 filings | Prior-year EFAST2 preparer entry anomalies tracked in dq_review |
Why 21.7% of Large Plans Report Line 4a Entries: Administrative Timing vs. Keying Errors
Because more than one in five audited U.S. employers report an entry on Line 4a, a reported figure most commonly reflects routine administrative timing rather than financial stress. Across corporate HR and treasury audits, three operational patterns account for the vast majority of disclosures:
- Post-Merger Payroll & HRIS Migrations: Acquiring a subsidiary with a separate payroll vendor or off-cycle bonus schedule frequently delays an automated SFTP remittance file to the recordkeeper by a few business days.
- Manual Off-Cycle Severance, Commission & Multi-Location Runs: Decentralized divisions or contributing employers remitting off-cycle adjustments manually settle slightly slower than the company's standard electronic feed.
- Carryover Reporting Across Plan Years: Under Form 5500 instructions, if a late 2023 payroll deposit has its lost-earnings make-whole credit completed in 2024, the principal amount is reported again on the 2024 Schedule H Line 4a to confirm correction.
| EIN / Plan | Employer / Plan Sponsor | State | Plan Net Assets | Reported Line 4a | Direct Admin Fee |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 34-0714775 / 003 | University Hospitals Health System | OH | $2.46B | $137.61M | 8.37 bps |
| 74-1648137 / 015 | Sysco Corporation | TX | $5.25B | $88.44M | 5.40 bps |
| 20-1305023 / 001 | Global Medical Response, INC. | CO | $1.75B | $74.12M | 13.77 bps |
| 13-3998945 / 002 | Moodys Corporation | NY | $2.08B | $68.62M | 3.70 bps |
| 52-2125995 / 001 | Bd Of Trustees Of The Elev Constu Annuity And 401k Ret Plan | PA | $7.29B | $53.24M | 5.74 bps |
| 98-0065088 / 001 | Barrick Gold Of North America, INC. | NV | $1.34B | $50.49M | 8.82 bps |
| 11-2656063 / 004 | Board Of Trustees Of The Deferred Salary Plan Of The Electrical Ind | NY | $7.99B | $39.16M | 11.26 bps |
| 26-3554645 / 025 | Acrisure, LLC | MI | $1.13B | $35.50M | 5.46 bps |
Interpreting Large Dollar Entries: Batch Payroll Timing & Preparer Keying Mistakes
ERISA practitioners evaluate a Line 4a dollar figure alongside Schedule H Line 2a(1)(B) (total annual participant contributions). As documented in Table 1 and visible among multi-tens-of-millions entries in Table 2, our data-quality pipeline annotates 337 filings in 2024 (and 380 in 2023) where third-party preparers either entered the plan's entire annual employee deferral payroll onto Line 4a or reported a single biweekly payroll batch that settled 24 to 48 hours after a holiday or vendor cutover.
Evaluating multi-year persistence across consecutive Form 5500 filings alongside employer matching contribution continuity provides essential context. In January 2025, EBSA updated its Voluntary Fiduciary Correction Program (VFCP) with a streamlined Self-Correction Component (SCC) for late participant contributions whose lost earnings total $1,000 or less, allowing sponsors to use the official DOL Online Calculator, file an electronic SCC notice, and document timely make-whole credits. Review Line 4a disclosures across peer employers in our ERISA Plan Explorer and read Briefing 04 on Plan Committee Governance.
Methodology & Analytical Scope Limitations
ERISA Ledger preserves official EFAST2 Line 4a dollar disclosures verbatim while annotating suspected full-payroll entry anomalies in dq_review so researchers can inspect raw ACK_ID filings alongside IQPA supplemental schedules; see Methodology.
Continue Exploring DOL Form 5500 Filings
Search any 9-digit EIN, corporate plan sponsor, or recordkeeper in ERISA Ledger, or read related briefings:
- Corporate 401(k) Recordkeeping & Administrative Fee Benchmarks: DOL Form 5500 Schedule H & Schedule C Distributions by Plan Asset Tier
- Indirect Compensation & Revenue Sharing in Employer Retirement Plans: Reviewing DOL Form 5500 Schedule C Disclosures
- How Plan Sponsors, Advisors & ERISA Counsel Benchmark Total Plan Cost Against Peer Cohorts