U.S. Retirement Plan Filings by Meru AI

Research Briefing 01 ยท 401(k) Scale Economics & Fee Compression

Corporate 401(k) Recordkeeping & Administrative Fee Benchmarks: DOL Form 5500 Schedule H & Schedule C Distributions by Plan Asset Tier

By Meru AI Published DOL Plan Year 2024 Rev a3a5a2d8c8fffe78

Across 63,379 audited defined-contribution retirement plans reconciled from U.S. Department of Labor Form 5500 Schedule H filings ($12.10T in 2024 plan assets across 94,511,046 active workers), median direct administrative fees compress 14.3x with scale, falling from 63.02 bps ($1M to $5M plans) to 4.40 bps (>$1B plans).

Why Employer Plan Asset Scale Drives 14.3x Administrative Fee Compression

Every large private-sector 401(k), 403(b), and profit-sharing plan subject to the Employee Retirement Income Security Act of 1974 (ERISA) must file an Independent Qualified Public Accountant (IQPA) financial audit on Form 5500 Schedule H with the U.S. Department of Labor Employee Benefits Security Administration (EBSA). Across all 73,075 audited plans in plan year 2024, trusts reported $21,554,053,327 ($21.55B) in direct administrative, recordkeeping, legal, and audit expenses.

Translating basis points into everyday saver terms clarifies why asset cohort matching is foundational under ERISA Section 404(a)(1)(B) prudence review: one basis point (1.0 bps = 0.01%) equals $1.00 per year per $10,000 in retirement savings ($10.00 per $100,000). Because core recordkeeping ledger administration, custody, Form 5500 compliance testing, and annual IQPA financial statement audits carry substantial fixed costs, smaller plans experience higher percentage expense ratios than mega-employers.

Table 1. U.S. Defined-Contribution Direct Administrative Fee Distribution by Plan Asset Tier (2024 DOL Schedule H)
Plan Asset Tier Audited DC Plans Cohort Net Assets P25 ($ / $10k) Median ($ / $10k) 90th Pct Screen Median / Worker
$1M-$5M 8,009 $27.79B 21.28 bps ($21.28) 63.02 bps ($63.02) 150.23 bps $107.39
$5M-$25M 30,060 $410.58B 13.96 bps ($13.96) 37.06 bps ($37.06) 80.82 bps $183.08
$25M-$100M 16,534 $852.48B 7.71 bps ($7.71) 19.23 bps ($19.23) 45.83 bps $154.34
$100M-$500M 6,329 $1.43T 4.63 bps ($4.63) 9.75 bps ($9.75) 25.89 bps $100.69
$500M-$1B 1,140 $849.61B 3.43 bps ($3.43) 6.25 bps ($6.25) 17.07 bps $74.36
>$1B 1,307 $5.55T 2.19 bps ($2.19) 4.40 bps ($4.40) 11.69 bps $62.05

Interpreting the 2024 Schedule H Curve: Per-Participant vs. Asset-Based Pricing

Table 1 illustrates two simultaneous patterns across the 63,379 denominator-hygienic defined-contribution plans in 2024:

  • Monotonic Basis-Point Compression: Median trust-billed expenses drop steadily from 63.02 bps ($63.02 per $10,000) in $1M-$5M plans to 37.06 bps in $5M-$25M, 19.23 bps in $25M-$100M, 9.75 bps in $100M-$500M, 6.25 bps in $500M-$1B, and 4.40 bps ($4.40 per $10,000) across the 1,307 mega-plans above $1B holding $5.55T.
  • The Mid-Market Per-Participant Peak ($183.08/worker): Median annual cost per active worker peaks in the $5M-$25M tier ($183.08) and $25M-$100M tier ($154.34) before compressing to $62.05 in >$1B plans. Mid-sized employers remaining on percentage-of-assets fee schedules see dollar charges rise alongside equity market appreciation unless committees negotiate fixed per-participant recordkeeping terms.

Nationwide, 6,335 defined-contribution plans sit at or above their own asset-tier 90th-percentile benchmark screen (150.23 bps for $1M-$5M; 45.83 bps for $25M-$100M; 11.69 bps for >$1B), providing a practical empirical threshold for periodic committee RFP review and fee negotiation.

Table 2. Leading Consolidated U.S. 401(k) Recordkeepers by Reconciled Client Plans & Schedule C Direct Compensation (2024)
Consolidated Recordkeeper Client Plans Client Plan Assets Direct Comp ($/yr) Client Median Fee Resolved Aliases
Fidelity Investments 13,362 $4.19T $1.29B 15.03 bps 663
Empower Retirement 9,770 $1.23T $811.20M 36.51 bps 706
Principal Financial Group 7,093 $793.71B $672.99M 36.94 bps 197
Vanguard 4,612 $1.79T $354.85M 14.57 bps 159
T. Rowe Price 4,423 $1.08T $142.03M 18.67 bps 278
ADP Retirement Services 4,262 $228.79B $126.10M 35.91 bps 71
John Hancock 3,949 $508.90B $173.26M 50.23 bps 364
TIAA 3,762 $745.48B $105.72M 12.06 bps 309

Why Vendor Medians Reflect Client Mix Rather Than Uniform Price Tags

In Table 2, entity resolution across 10,266 raw Schedule C name and EIN variants shows Fidelity Investments administering 13,362 audited plans ($4.19T, client median 15.03 bps), Empower Retirement administering 9,770 plans ($1.23T, 36.51 bps), Principal Financial Group administering 7,093 plans ($793.71B, 36.94 bps), and Vanguard administering 4,612 plans ($1.79T, 14.57 bps). A provider serving thousands of $5M-$25M plans naturally posts a higher overall client median than a platform concentrated in >$500M corporate trusts, which is why fair vendor evaluation always compares recordkeepers within identical asset tiers.

Evaluating Sponsor-Absorbed Expenses vs. Participant Account Deductions

Plan committees also distinguish employer-paid invoices from participant-deducted trust expenses. Across mega-employers exceeding $1B, dozens of large sponsors pay recordkeeping and IQPA audit invoices out of corporate operating accounts so Schedule H reports $0 in trust-billed administrative cost, whereas mid-market plans commonly allocate per-account or pro-rata basis-point fees across participant balances. Read Briefing 02 on Schedule C Revenue Sharing or explore our Fee Scale Curve & Peer Benchmarks.

Methodology & Statutory Disclosure Limitations

Direct administrative basis points equal (Schedule H Total Administrative Expenses / Average Plan Net Assets) * 10,000 across plans with at least $1M in average assets; 12,410 zero-asset/terminating plans, 2,173 negative reversals, and 1,455 extreme (>500 bps) entries are quarantined. Schedule H captures trust-billed expenses and does not capture internal mutual-fund investment management expense ratios unless routed through plan accounts; see Methodology.